Proving You’re the Primary Carer in Divorce and Custody Cases

⚠️ Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and not legal advice. Always seek advice from a qualified family lawyer about your personal situation.

When parents separate, one of the biggest questions the Family Court has to answer is: “Who is the primary carer of the children?”

It’s not about who loves the kids more or who earns the most money. Instead, it’s about the practical, day-to-day reality of who meets the children’s needs — physically, emotionally, and developmentally. And if you’re in the middle of a divorce or parenting dispute, being able to prove your role as the primary carer can significantly shape custody outcomes.

What Does “Primary Carer” Mean in Family Law?

Under Australian family law, the “primary carer” is usually the parent who has taken the lead role in looking after the children before separation. This can include:

• Who gets the kids ready for school

• Who attends medical appointments

• Who provides meals, clothing, and day-to-day care

• Who comforts them when they’re upset

• Who maintains routines like bedtime or homework

It’s not about grand gestures — it’s about the consistent, daily responsibilities that form the foundation of a child’s life.

Why Does It Matter in Custody Cases?

When courts make interim parenting orders (temporary orders until a final hearing), they place strong weight on who has historically been the primary carer. The logic is simple: stability is in the best interests of the child.

If you’ve been the main caregiver, the court is more likely to continue that arrangement while longer-term custody is determined.

How to Prove You’re the Primary Carer

Here’s where many parents get stuck: How do you actually prove it in court? Some key steps include:

• Keep a parenting diary – Document daily routines, school drop-offs, doctor’s visits, and extracurricular activities.

• Gather evidence – School attendance records, medical notes, texts, or emails showing your involvement.

• Witness statements – Teachers, coaches, or family members who can confirm your caregiving role.

• Stay child-focused – Courts look for stability and care, not conflict and blame.

The Role of Family Violence in Custody Decisions

If there are allegations of family violence or coercive control, this heavily influences custody outcomes. A parent may have been the primary carer, but if safety concerns arise, the court must consider protective measures.

Common Misunderstandings

• Babysitters and grandparents don’t make someone the primary carer. The court wants to know who you are in your children’s lives.

   

Final Thoughts

If you’re going through a separation, proving your role as the primary carer is crucial. Keep records, stay calm, and focus on the children’s best interests. And remember — even in high-conflict cases, the court is guided by one principle above all: what’s best for the kids.

Listen to This Episode If…

👩‍👧 You’re in a custody dispute and want to show the court you’re the primary carer

⚖️ You’re unsure what “primary carer” really means under family law

📚 You need to know what kind of evidence proves you’ve been the day-to-day parent

😟 You’re worried your ex is twisting the truth about who cares for the kids

📝 You want practical tips on documenting your role as the main caregiver

🏛️ You’re preparing for mediation or family court and want to feel more confident

💡 You want to understand how judges assess who the primary carer is

⚠️ Trigger Warning: This episode discusses family and domestic violence, coercive control, and financial abuse.
📌 Legal Disclaimer: This episode is for general information only and is not legal advice. Please seek independent advice for your specific situation.

primary carer. What does it actually mean? How do courts define it? Why does it matter so much in custody battles and interim hearings? And most importantly, how can you prove you’ve been the primary carer if your ex tries to rewrite history?

We unpack the recent changes in family law in Australia, the shift away from the old 50/50 presumption, and why the courts now focus on the best interests of the children over parental entitlement. Along the way, we share practical examples, strategies for gathering evidence, and insights into how controlling or manipulative ex-partners sometimes exploit this concept.

Whether you’re negotiating custody in mediation, preparing for court, or simply trying to understand your rights, this episode is for you.

⏱️ Episode Timeline – What We Discuss

• 00:00 – What does “primary carer” mean in divorce and custody cases?
• 02:08 – How do courts define the role of a primary carer in family law?
• 03:46 – What changes in family law affect interim parenting orders?
• 06:50 – How do judges decide the “best interests of the children”?
• 16:07 – How can you prove you are the primary carer in custody disputes?
• 23:13 – What practical steps help parents show primary carer status?
• 23:37 – When should you seek legal or psychological support in custody battles?
• 23:48 – How do you handle high-conflict separations in family court?
• 24:07 – What role do parenting plans play in custody and court proceedings?
• 25:38 – How does family violence impact child custody decisions?
• 28:01 – Do grandparents and babysitters count in proving primary carer status?
• 30:29 – What is the “first right of refusal” in custody arrangements?
• 34:39 – What evidence do you need to prove you’re the main carer for your children?
• 41:59 – Final thoughts and encouragement for parents in custody cases
  
  

📌 Links & Resources Mentioned

• Cowlings Case : https://www.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/FedJSchol/2002/2.pdf
• The Purple Book https://domesticviolence.com.au/resources/the-purple-book/
• Family Law Changes episode https://open.spotify.com/episode/4nPB5tKDwMC95G9IrFXGSq?si=SeyXIoDDRN-MJy4Q513WAQ
• Family Law Act Australia Definition of Family Violence https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/legis/cth/consol_act/fla1975114/s4ab.html
• Family Law Act Section 61DAB https://www.austlii.edu.au/cgi-bin/viewdoc/au/legis/cth/consol_act/fla1975114/s61dab.html
• Safeguarding against unfair accusations in Family Court Custody Battles https://open.spotify.com/episode/2vgyr4S8LWECnqspEfrdij?si=-oZRAP06S7yTNGVxHyV4GQ
•  
• Enrol now: The Divorce Course https://www.thedivorcecourse.com.au/enrol

🆘 Support Services

💜 1800 RESPECT – Domestic and Family Violence Support
📞 Lifeline – 13 11 14 (24/7 Crisis Support)
⚖️ Legal Aid – Visit your state’s Legal Aid website
👧 Kids Helpline – 1800 55 1800